Imprivata and Zebra Technologies Flash Insights 2023
New Partnership Presents Potential Solution for Fleet Management
The number of shared smart devices (i.e., smartphones and tablets) in use at hospitals has risen dramatically. These devices are small and difficult to manage without strict internal processes. Challenges can include fleet setup, ongoing maintenance, establishing robust yet easy-to-use authentication protocols, infection control, location tracking, and the potential for PHI loss or cybersecurity threats.
A recently announced partnership between Imprivata and Zebra Technologies is intended to help address some of these challenges, integrating Imprivata’s GroundControl solution with Zebra’s fleet of shared smart devices. No healthcare organizations have yet adopted the integrated pairing, but KLAS has historically gathered data on the solutions separately, offering a glimpse of the potential benefits and hurdles.
The Challenges of Managing Shared Smart Devices
Shared smart devices continue to replace handheld phones and other legacy devices in the nurse tool belt. Enabling voice and asynchronous communication (through downloadable secure messaging apps), smart devices improve communication and efficiency and help streamline clinical workflows. However, they also come with significant financial costs, security threats (e.g., from lost or stolen devices), and manual, labor-intensive processes to deploy, secure, and maintain at scale while also ensuring adoption and ease of use for end users. While mobile device management (MDM) solutions help address some of the security challenges, additional technology is needed to optimize fleet management.
Potential Benefits and Hurdles of the Imprivata and Zebra Technologies Partnership
The newly announced integration between Imprivata and Zebra Technologies is intended to deliver automated device management workflows, secure device checkout, and secure application access for Android users. Based on KLAS’ assessment of each product’s individual strengths, it appears the partnership could have a significant impact on communication workflows and make it easier for healthcare organizations to manage large fleets of communication devices. The following sections explore the integration’s potential benefits and hurdles:
Potential benefits
- Enables device checkout via a badge tap and enables multifactor authentication on the device itself
- Prevents users from checking out devices without authenticating via a trusted digital identity
- Enables a device-level PIN rather than an app-level PIN, thus eliminating the need for users to log back in to apps every 15 minutes; logging in to the device via a badge tap also logs the user in to all integrated applications
- Provides audit trail of user access, including who, where, when, and which device
- Enables stolen or lost devices to be wiped clean
- Leverages Imprivata’s other security offerings to protect against cybersecurity threats
Potential hurdles
- Healthcare organizations have unique needs and requirements:Â Vendor partnerships and new product developments often encounter unforeseen hurdles. While GroundControl has been successfully rolled out to iOS customers, the Zebra integration includes new, as-yet-unvetted features. Additionally, there are no healthcare-specific Zebra customers to date (one non-healthcare organization has adopted the integration). Any alpha or beta Zebra customers may uncover healthcare-specific challenges to address. Failure to resolve these early hurdles could lead to ongoing difficulties for later adopters.
- Operating system updates sometimes cause functionality issues: Many technology partnerships don’t fully test to ensure updates in one product don’t break functionality in the other. Imprivata’s iOS customers have reported complaints about this in the past, so Imprivata and Zebra have an opportunity to invest in sufficient testing prior to rolling out updates.
A Closer Look at Imprivata GroundControl
Imprivata is a digital security and authentication company with multiple security products. They acquired the GroundControl solution in 2019. GroundControl is live with iOS devices and has been developed for Android devices as well (KLAS has not validated live Android users). The following high-level insights come from GroundControl customers interviewed for research KLAS published in November 2021.
Imprivata Customer Experience: An Initial Look
Note: The following findings are a reflection of the general GroundControl customer experience and do not include user insights on the GroundControl/Zebra integration specifically.
Strengths of GroundControl
- Automates device tracking and end-user access
- Easy to scale across large organizations
- Vendor provides strong support resources with robust knowledge
Opportunities for improvement with GroundControl
- Hardware integration challenges
- Functionality issues after iOS updates
Note: Data comes from research KLAS published on Imprivata GroundControl in November 2021. Additional data about the GroundControl customer experience can be found in KLAS’ 2022 report on Imprivata’s broader digital identity platform.
A Closer Look at Zebra Technologies’ Shared Smart Devices
Zebra Technologies is a mobile smart device company whose devices are built specifically to be used in rugged settings (i.e., manufacturing and healthcare) and are deployed as fleet phone systems. Zebra recently rolled out the Zebra TC52-HC handheld smart devices. KLAS published research in February 2022 outlining customers’ initial feedback. These customers typically reported high satisfaction with the customizability of the Android-based TC52-HC and reported plans to leverage the devices long term. Customers who chose the TC52-HC over other devices, such as iPhones, noted its durability, hot-swappable batteries, built-in barcode readers, and other healthcare-specific tools, like the staff duress or panic button.
Zebra Technologies Customer Experience: An Initial Look
Note: The following findings are a reflection of the general Zebra customer experience and do not include user insights on the GroundControl/Zebra integration specifically.
Strengths of the TC52-HC
- Better grill design and call quality than older models
- Better Wi-Fi testing during implementation
Opportunities for improvement with the TC52-HC
- Bulkiness of the device is a limitation compared to competitors; however, customers can roll out the slimmer TC21 (Wi-Fi only) or TC26 (Wi-Fi or SIM card) to non-nurses that don’t need barcoding
- Low executive involvement from Zebra
- Learning curve for users not familiar with Android devices
Note: Data comes from research KLAS published on Zebra Technologies’ shared smart devices in February 2022.
About This Report
This Flash Insights report is intended to give provider organizations quick insights into the recently announced partnership between Imprivata and Zebra Technologies. It is important to note that the scores and ratings reflected in the report are based on customer evaluations of the vendors’ separate offerings. No healthcare organizations are yet live with the integration.
Writer
Elizabeth Pew
Designer
Jess Wallace-Simpson
Project Manager
Andrew Wright
This material is copyrighted. Any organization gaining unauthorized access to this report will be liable to compensate KLAS for the full retail price. Please see the KLAS DATA USE POLICY for information regarding use of this report. © 2025 KLAS Research, LLC. All Rights Reserved. NOTE: Performance scores may change significantly when including newly interviewed provider organizations, especially when added to a smaller sample size like in emerging markets with a small number of live clients. The findings presented are not meant to be conclusive data for an entire client base.